So, this is a follow up to the 01.19.06 dispatch. Apparently I had more to say than I thought. Last week I said I thought the church should be involved in sex-ed. I don’t know that I can say that what I think applies to all people, Christian or otherwise. Because I was asked, I will try. I don’t know if it is right or wrong. But it is part of what I was thinking about. It got really long, so I choose to post it as a dispatch instead of in the comments. Anyway –
I always thought that if Christians and the Church were serious about raising Christians in a secular world they would openly discuss sex, desire and all the other tangled emotions that emerging adults experience, instead of just referring us to the Song of Solomon or complaining that the school system is teaching promiscuity and homosexuality and opting us out of sex-ed.
Isn't the church in the business of instilling morals and values in young Christians? Shouldn't we be allowed to discuss what is affecting us in a setting that is comforting to us, as well as one that shapes our world-views?
I know. I'm not really expanding on my initial statement. Let me see if I can clarify.
Why I think the church should be involved in teaching sex-ed. Of course this pre-supposes that you are interested in the church and its teachings in your life.
I want the church involved to help emerging adult realize that sex is not dirty. It is wonderful and beautiful and like all gifts from God – it should be cared for and not treated lightly. All that being said, we still need to educate our emerging adults and talk with them about the risks and dangers of sex in a very serious way.
What I remember from public school sex-ed, they taught mechanics and answered some questions about developmental changes. They dealt with the physical actions and consequences of those actions. Where were the emotional and moral consequences of those actions taught? As much as I want to answer the question “either in the home or in church” my guess would be that those consequences were not. I don’t know if that it was because of fear or a reluctance to talk about something considered indecent.
I have a much more liberal attitude on talking about sex because of how frank my mom was/ is. All those sexual health classes and HIV awareness classes that she taught that we kids got taken to sunk in. But all I got from the church was "Don't have sex until you are married and don't masturbate. It's a sin. Oh yeah, Homosexuality is an abomination before God."
OK. That was the answer with no more explanation or discussion. Yeah. That didn't help us or happen. (With me or any of the people I associated with in my youth group or Young Life. Nor did it help my friend/s with his/their emerging homosexuality. )
So where were we supposed to learn? I can tell you where we did learn. I'll be frank - it was not the marriage bed. As with all teenage boys there was a healthy trade in porn, and we talked with other guys – some Christian, some not. Even worse, we learned with girls in our youth group. (Well - I did anyway. And they were as confused as me about what we were doing - not just the mechanics. The whole situation was messed up.)
I had all the knowledge that mom could arm me with. I knew enough to be safe and why I didn't want to have intercourse. Well, let me rephrase - I wanted it, but I restrained from having it when offered (some of the time anyway). Not that it was offered all that regularly but enough.
I couldn't talk to any one. Not my pastor (and be shunned in church? hah!) Not my mom (just. NO.) And all my non-Christian friends didn't understand why I was upset (dude! You are having SEX! SHUT UP.). I know I hurt one young lady because things between us got out of hand and I ended it. I don't think I explained myself or why I felt that things had to end - they just did and so I did.
You end up in unhealthy situations that way.
Christ, I read all that and it sounds to me like we were all having sex all the time. No we were not. Of course it happened. I ran with damaged people and damaged people engage in self destructive behavior a little more openly than the rest of the world. That is not really the point. So sex was offered. So were drugs and alcohol. I stayed away from drugs and alcohol, but not so much with the sex. It was a struggle. How can you live up to an ideal when the people you should be talking to about this – won’t talk about it.
“It is a sin to have sex (any kind of sex) before marriage. It is a sin to masturbate. Don’t talk about it.”
It felt like it was a sin to talk about it.
I don’t mean to be indelicate… but I think that we need candor in a discussion of this sort. If you can’t talk about it, what is the point?
I think my Young Life leader (one of them) was as open and honest about it as he could be. He expressed the same frustrations that we all did and why he struggled with it and how he dealt with it. My first real experience with a Christian mentor and he was honest about that part of his life. We never talked mechanics - but spiritual and emotional consequences were discussed. In retrospect, it gave me hope. I was not abnormal in context.
You know, we all masturbate at some point. We all have fantasies. We all lust. We all make mistakes. We just need to talk about it.
After all of this, I still don’t know how I feel about pre-marital sex. Knowing what I know now, I would rather teenagers were not dipping their toes in that pool. I don’t think they are prepared for the responsibility of it. I am not inclined to tell adults how to live their lives. It’s not my business what they do.
Sexuality and Reproduction -- things that are beautiful, wonderful, inspiring and oh yeah, created by God.
Exactly. So why is it that we won't talk about it? I mean mechanics, consequences (emotional and physical) etc, etc. I'm not trying to be titillating here, but why not have these discussions? I know. I’m on my soapbox again. I’m not advocating a sex tips class for teenagers, but I am advocating an educational class that covers all the same things we covered in sex-ed (at a bare minimum).
Another question I have always had (and this is really for the adults – not the kids) is "If sex if for procreation only - why make it feel so good? Why do I get an electric feeling when my (insert partner here) touches me?" I know it's biological and the reproductive reasoning - but it seems to make sense to me that God gave us a gift that allows us to explore our partner’s body and find pleasure in that. So why deny that it is good in the correct context?
I find it interesting that Islam is having these sorts of debates, but much more openly. I linked to it a few days back - but one of the side articles that came up as a result of the marriage valid/ invalid fatwa was on the topic of what was acceptable between man and wife in the marriage bed. From what I read, the Shi’a Muslim teachers have said essentially - in the marriage bed - anything goes between husband and wife, but some things do not glorify God as highly as others. There is disagreement on that as well, but they are talking about sex in context to religion and marriage.
The kick is that so many teens I know were opted out of sex-ed where they might have received some warnings about the physical consequences - and their parents/ church never talked to them about the emotional consequences. I read it in the news. I hear about it from the Preachers Kids I have met and the ones that were cloistered their whole life.
Shouldn’t we be caring for these people before the fact, not just after? Isn't that our place as parents and as members of the church?
Wow – soapbox. I didn’t mean to ramble on so. It just sort of came out this way. I edited the stuff that seemed irrelevant to the discussion or too personal. It probably still crosses that line.